Review: The Shape of Water (2017)

Guillermo del Toro delivers a gorgeous love-letter to Jack Arnold’s Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954). Peppered with social commentary, brimming with gripping performances, and featuring a unique take on the ‘beauty and beast’ tale, The Shape of Water is Del Toro’s mastery for monsters distilled to fine simplicity.

Set in Baltimore in the early 1960s, Elisa (Sally Hawkins) works as a night cleaner at a government facility. Although mute, she still has her friend and workmate Zelda (Octavia Spencer) to keep her company. Zelda often helpfully communicates on behalf of Elisa when someone doesn’t understand sign language. At home, Elisa lives next door to her friend, Giles (Richard Jenkins), a struggling advertisement painter. One evening, Elisa witnesses a new arrival to the facility – an imposing container filled with water. Peering in, Elisa is one of the first to see the Amphibian Man (Doug Jones); an aquatic humanoid captured in South America and brought to America for study. It isn’t long before the Amphibian Man notices Elisa, and the pair forms an unmistakable, deepening connection. However, Strickland (Michael Shannon), the overseeing government official, has more sinister, barbaric plans for the aquatic athlete…

This is arguably a story about downtrodden people surviving in a world that doesn’t want to acknowledge them. It is a tragic premise, but it’s one that allows for an enriching exploration of friendship and love. All of our protagonists here are, in one way or another, demoralized and exploited people. Elisa and Zelda are disregarded as cleaners. Giles’ paintings of idyllic nuclear families fail to earn the respect of his employers; and, as we discover, so does he. Last but not least, the Amphibian Man has been ripped from his home and subjected to torture, seen only as a possible means to an end.

Sally Hawkins as Elisa.

The Shape of Water is a good story because of Guillermo Del Toro’s expression of truth. Aesthetically, the film borrows not just from Creature from the Black Lagoon, but also from several 1950s creature features. Whilst many of those films are arguably overlooked gems, there are those without truth to their stories. Characters often behave according to the needs of the plot, and not to truthful human emotion. Take I Was A Teenage Werewolf (1957) for example. It is a highly entertaining film, but the titular werewolf only appears because a psychologist treating the young man believes that mankind’s only salvation from self-destruction is to be regressed back to a primitive, beastly form – not necessarily convincing.

In The Shape of Water, Del Toro’s characters behave and develop along deeply humanistic lines. Their actions correspond to emotions, not plot points, and in those moments of character depth, Del Toro weaves a truthful narrative.

Take Sally Hawkins’ Elisa, for example. Her decision to let go of everything for love demonstrates the power of emotion. Elisa is willing to let every vestige of her already unconventional life fall away to leap into a romantic taboo. Love is an unstoppable force, and it’s clear that Del Toro understands this precisely.

Sally Hawkins projects that deep romance wonderfully. At first, without a single word spoken, she communicates a palpable need for intimacy; presenting it both comically and seriously. Once she has begun her brilliant love with the Amphibian Man, her performance shifts. She is still the vulnerable woman we were introduced to, but that part of her becomes secondary to the connection she’s found. The joy she’s found flows from Hawkins’ infectious facial expressions. When Elisa smiles, we smile.

Elisa (Sally Hawkins) and the Amphibian Man (Doug Jones) share a moment.

The other half of that love is Doug Jones’, Amphibian Man. His performance is outstanding. Building on what performers like Ben Chapman established when turning the Gill Man of Creature from the Black Lagoon into a character, Doug Jones projects the Amphibian Man with nuance and grace. At times graceful and in others beastly, Doug Jones sustains the complexity of humanity in an inhuman form. The practical suit used is sublime. It retains the form of the Gill Man, but has the unmistakable touch of Del Toro, calling to mind a certain character from his Hellboy films.

Legacy Effects and creature designers Shane Mahan and Mike Hill crafted a stunning practical suit that Doug Jones breathes life into. On top of this, VFX studio Mr. X layered CGI onto the facial features to add subtle movements to further capture a living organism. Nine times out of ten, those CGI augmentations are completely unnoticeable – a credit to Dennis Berardi’s visual effects team. The practical suit and how Director of Photography Dan Lausten’s lighting hits it reminds the audience that the Amphibian Man is physically real and in that space. Meanwhile, the digital touches from Berardi’s team add the subtle movements of a living character.

Del Toro inspects the Amphibian Man (Doug Jones)

Perhaps one of the most interesting aspects of The Shape of Water is how Del Toro uses familiar beats from 1950s science fiction and uses them to develop the narrative. In doing so, he not only pays tribute to those films that have influenced him but manages to bolster his film’s meaning as well. In films like Tarantula (1955), The Deadly Mantis (1957), It Came from Beneath the Sea (1955), and in the Gill Man trilogy – particularly Revenge of the Creature (1955) – women consistently have interesting occupations such as journalists or scientists; and yet the men around them constantly dismiss or objectify them. This is also the case in The Shape of Water, with Strickland’s domineering gaze leaving the audience as uncomfortable as Elisa, yet the intention behind its inclusion is sharply different. Del Toro includes the kinds of casual sexist remarks prevalent in 1950s science fiction and uses them to build character. With Michael Shannon’s insidious Strickland, it makes him into a monster. With Octavia Spencer’s Zelda and Sally Hawkins’ Elisa, it shapes them into underdog women heroes. In doing this, Del Toro directly references his inspirations but truthfully appropriates their outdated social shortcomings for the betterment of the story.

The Shape of Water is a film that basks in the warmth of humanity. It subjects us to frighteningly real terrors to make us aware of what matters: those we love. Of course, that great love is not exclusively romantic. It appears several times in the compassion and loyalty shared between friends. In amongst the references to Creature from the Black Lagoon, the beautiful production design, and truthful performances is a film that celebrates seeing beauty all around us. Guillermo Del Toro has masterfully told a story that communicates the core of his worldview, and in turn, touches ours. If the purpose of a film is to touch the soul, then The Shape of Water has succeeded.





Sound Selection 089: Bicep Present ‘Atlas’

All My Friends Hate Me Not In This Economy Entering with a rebellious, self-deprecating tone and energy are All My Friends Hate Me with Not In...

Albums Out Today: Thundercat, Purity Ring, Yves Tumor, Peach Pit

In this segment, we showcase the most notable albums out each week. Here are the albums out on April 3rd, 2020: Thundercat, It Is What...

Video Premiere: KOKO ‘Freak’

KOKO, a highly-exciting project that turns up the level on Pop music, revealed their music video for their song Freak. The song drives on...

House on the Cliff by Fran Silvestre Arquitectos

Fran Silvestre Arquitectos, the beloved studio based out of Valencia, Spain, presented a beautiful project which thet named House on the Cliff, among many...

Little Thief Present New Song ‘All Our Sins’

After a successful release of Doctor, the band known as Little Thief released their latest single All Our Sins just a few days ago. Little Thief's...

Editor's choice

The Shape of Revenge: Revenge of the Creature and The Shape of Water

Since the release of Guillermo Del Toro’s The Shape of Water (2017), much has been said of its threads to Jack Arnold’s Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954). An...

Conversations with Frances Ha: The Intersection Between Sally Rooney’s Millennial Fiction and Greta Gerwig’s Mumblecore Classic

It might sound quite frivolous to compare two works of fiction based on the mere fact that their protagonists share the same name, but...

Back to Sincerity, Hope, and Love: Metamodernism in Sci-Fi

Science fiction films are often expressions of highly complex philosophical ideas. By utilizing genre tropes such as time travel, artificial intelligence, and space exploration,...

Inglourious Basterds at 10

Please note: This article from the offset contains spoilers for Inglourious Basterds and other Tarantino movies, including Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood. This month...

Comparison: Rocketman vs. Bohemian Rhapsody

Two musical biopics. Two flamboyant, iconic British Rockstars who had their own demons, pitfalls and tough critics. And one director (kind of) - in...